A few months
back I was home sick, my wife Diane was at work and I just wanted to lie on the
couch and do nothing. I decided to watch a movie on cable that I knew Diane wouldn't be interested in watching.
First let me give you a little background as to what we
usually like to watch or not watch. We don’t like anything with graphic
violence, if it has too much action we get all wound up and can’t get to sleep.
Stupid comedies are just a waste of time and horror flicks, well they are
usually a combination of all of the above. So what does that leave? Chick
flicks, not to violent suspense thrillers, romantic comedies, documentaries, and
period movies of classic novels. Realistically we don’t watch too many movies
and the same criteria apply to TV shows.
The movie I decided to watch was the American version of “The
Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” based on a Swedish novel and movie. I had seen the
previews and ads on TV so I knew it was a “mystery thriller” but what I didn't expect was the level of graphic violence it contained. I mean for me it was so
disturbing that I couldn't get the images out of my mind for weeks.
The story line about a serial killer of young women was bad
enough with images of the dead victims but to me that doesn't even compare to
the graphic depiction of “Anal Rape”. Not once but twice in the same movie.
First the female lead is raped then later she revenge rapes her male rapist,
both in way to graphic detail.
This brings me to a question I have to ask because I really
don’t understand how and why this kind of imagery has become acceptable
entertainment. When did so many in our society become desensitized to the
reality of violence? One of the reasons I tell myself that I don’t watch
violent images is precisely because I don’t want to become desensitized to the
horror of violence. If I’m walking down the street and see someone who’s been
victimized, I want to feel their pain and anguish. I want to empathize with
them not ignore them.
The problem is that it’s getting harder and harder to not be
desensitized. We are constantly bombarded with news images and information
about all the violence in the world. Whether its man-made wars, crime, or even
accidental violence we see the images. Then there’s Mother Nature with all her
destructive power. Hurricanes, earthquakes, floods, droughts, and everything
else she can throw at us, we see images of it all.
With all that real violence all around us, why do we entertain
ourselves with fake violence? That’s really my question because I just don’t
get it. Maybe it’s just me because I've never been a violent person. I've never
been in a fight, I've never hunted or purposely killed anything (yes I feel a
little guilt that animals are killed to feed me but that’s another column), and I've never had any violence against me. Or maybe it’s because unconsciously I’m
trying to not be reminded of the real life “Unsolved Murder Mystery”
surrounding my younger sister’s death when we were teenagers.
Or maybe it’s because there is so much uncontrolled violence
all around us that we do want to be desensitized to it. I can kind of
understand that, needing to be desensitized so as not to go a little nuts
worrying about something out of our control.
But being desensitized and being entertained, those are two
very different things and I still don’t get it. Let me give you one last
example and story from my life. As a
young man way back in the 70’s I watched all the Muhammad Ali boxing matches
and I cheered him on and was in awe of his ability to inflict and receive pain.
I was entertained and didn't really give it much thought. Somewhere in my late
teens a friend invited me to go with him to watch a live golden gloves
competition. That was a turning point in my attitude about violence for
entertainments sake. Watching a bunch of 8 and 10 year olds trying to beat each
other up was hard enough but watching and listening to all the adults cheer and
egg them on was to me disgusting, socially sick, and even immoral. It just felt
wrong and it still does.
My feeling is that humans as a species and people as part of
a society will never advance or evolve into peace and harmony as long as we are
entertained and not appalled by violence and pain. So maybe human nature won’t
allow us to advance without violence but I can still fantasize about a peaceful
future and that fantasy, that’s what I call entertainment.
To view the column in it's original form go to page 15 of the following link. Winters Express 11/22/12